Ours
was a house for children, rather than a real school. We had
prepared a place for children where a diffused culture could be
assimilated, without any need for direct instruction...Yet these
children learned to read and write before they were five, and no
one had given them any lessons. At that time it seemed
miraculous that children of four and a half should be able to
write, and that they should have learned without the feeling of
having been taught.
We puzzled over it for a long time. Only after repeated
experiments did we conclude with certainty that all children are
endowed with this capacity to 'absorb' culture. If this be true
- we then argued - if culture can be acquired without effort,
let us provide the children with other elements of culture. And
then we saw them 'absorb' far more than reading and writing:
botany, zoology, mathematics, geography, and all with the same
ease, spontaneously and without getting tired.
And so we discovered that education is not something which the
teacher does, but that it is a natural process which develops
spontaneously in the human being. It is not acquired by
listening to words, but in virtue of experiences in which the
child acts on his environment. , but to prepare and arrange a
series of motives for cultural activity in a special environment
made for the child.
My experiments, conducted in many different countries, have now
been going on for forty years (ed. now eighty-five years), and
as the children grew up parents kept asking me to extend my
methods to the later ages. We then found that individual
activity is the one factor that stimulates and produces
development, and that this is not more true for the little ones
of preschool age than it is for the junior, middle, and upper
school children.
The Absorbent Mind
Dr. Maria Montessori
Montessori the Innovator
Maria Montessori is as controversial a figure in
education today as she was a half century ago. Alternately
heralded as the century's leading advocate for early childhood
education, or dismissed as outdated and irrelevant, her research
and the studies that she inspired helped change the course of
education.
Those who studied under her and went on to make their own
contributions to education and child psychology include Anna
Freud, Jean Piaget, Alfred Adler, and Erik Erikson. Many
elements of modern education have been adapted from Montessori's
theories. She is credited with the development of the open
classroom, individualized education, manipulative learning
materials, teaching toys, and programmed instruction. In the
last thirty-five years educators in Europe and North America
begun to recognize the consistency between of the Montessori
approach with what we have learned from research into child
development.
A Pioneering Woman
Maria Montessori was an individual ahead of her
time. She was born in 1870 in Ancona, Italy, to an educated but
nonaffluent middle class family. She grew up in a country
considered most conservative in its attitude toward women, yet
even against the considerable opposition of her father and
teachers, Montessori pursued a scientific education and was the
first woman to become a physician in Italy. As a practicing
physician associated with the University of Rome, she was a
scientist, not a teacher. It is ironic that she became famous
for her contributions in a field that she had rejected as the
traditional refuge for women at a time when few professions were
open to them other than homemaking or the convent. The
Montessori method evolved almost by accident from a small
experiment that Dr. Montessori carried out on the side. Her
genius stems not from her teaching ability, but from her
recognition of the importance of what she stumbled upon.
A Humanistic Scientist
As a physician, Dr. Montessori specialized in
paediatrics and psychiatry. She taught at the medical school of
the University of Rome, and through its free clinics she came
into frequent contact with the children of the working class and
poor. These experiences convinced her that intelligence is not
rare and that most new born children come into the world with a
human potential that will be barely revealed.
Her work reinforced her humanistic ideals, and she made time in
her busy schedule to actively support various social reform
movements. Early in her career she began to accept speaking
engagements throughout Europe on behalf of the women's movement,
peace efforts, and child labor law reform. Montessori become
well known and highly regarded throughout Europe, which
undoubtedly contributed to the publicity that surrounded her
schools.
An Opportunity to Study Children
In 1901 Montessori was appointed Director of the
new orthophrenic school attached to the University of Rome,
formerly used as the asylum for the "deficient and insane"
children of the city, most of whom were probably retarded or
autistic. She initiated a wave of reform in a system that
formerly had served merely to confine mentally handicapped
youngsters in empty rooms. Recognizing her patients' need for
stimulation, purposeful activity, and self-esteem, Montessori
insisted that the staff speak to the inmates with the highest
respect. She set up a program to teach her young charges how to
care for themselves and their environment.
At the same time, she began a meticulous study of all research
previously done on the education of the mentally handicapped.
Her studies led Montessori to the work of two almost forgotten
French physicians of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries:
Jean Itard and Edouard Seguin.
The Discovery of "Sensitive Periods"
Itard is most famous for his work with the "Wild
Boy Of Aveyron," a youth who had been found wandering naked in
the forest, having spent 10 years living alone. The boy could
not speak and lacked almost all of the skills of everyday life.
Here apparently was a "natural man;" a human being who had
developed without the benefit of culture and socialization with
his own kind. Itard hoped from this study to shed some light on
the age-old debate about what proportion of human intelligence
and personality is hereditary and what proportion stems from
learned behaviour.
Itard's experiment was a limited success, for Itard found the
"wild boy" uncooperative and unwilling or unable to learn most
things. This led Itard to postulate the existence of
developmental periods in normal human growth. During these
"sensitive periods" a child must experience stimulation or grow
up forever lacking adult skills and intellectual concepts that
he missed at the stage when they can be readily learned!
Although Itard's efforts to teach the wild boy were barely
successful, he followed a methodical approach in designing the
process, arguing that all education would benefit from the use
of careful observation and experimentation. This idea had
tremendous appeal to the scientifically trained Montessori, and
later became the cornerstone of her method.
Montessori Develops a Scientific Approach
From Edouard Seguin, Montessori drew further
confirmation of Itard's work, along with a far more specific and
organized system for applying it to the everyday education of
the handicapped. Today Seguin is recognized as the father of our
modern techniques of special education for the retarded.
From these two predecessors, Montessori took the idea of a
scientific approach to education, based on observation and
experimentation. She belongs to the Child Study school of
thought, and she pursued her work with the careful training and
objectivity of the biologist studying the natural behaviour of an
animal in the forest.
Sensational Success
She studied her retarded youngsters, listening and carefully
noting everything that they did and said. Slowly she began to
get a sense of who they really were and what methods worked
best. Her success was given widespread notice when, two years
after she began, many of Montessori's "deficient" adolescents
were able to pass the standard sixth grade tests of the Italian
public schools. Acclaimed for this "miracle," Montessori
responded by suggesting that her results proved only that public
schools should be able to get dramatically better results with
normal children.
Greeted with Skepticism
Unfortunately, the Italian Ministry of Education
did not welcome this idea, and she was denied access to
school-aged children. Frustrated in her efforts to carry the
experiment on with public school students, in 1907 Montessori
jumped at the chance to coordinate a series of day-care centres
for working-class children who were too young to attend public
school.
"Children's Houses" Begin
These "Children's Houses" were located in the
worst slum district of Rome, and the conditions Montessori faced
were appalling. Her first class consisted of fifty children from
two through five years of age, taught by one untrained
caregiver. The children remained at the centre from dawn to dusk
while their parents worked. They had to be fed two meals a day,
bathed regularly, and given a program of medical care.
The children themselves were typical of extreme inner-city
poverty conditions. They entered school the first day crying and
pushing, exhibiting generally aggressive and impatient behaviour.
Montessori, not knowing whether her experiment would work under
such conditions, began by teaching the older children how to
help out with the everyday tasks that needed to be done. She
also introduced the manipulative perceptual puzzles that she had
used with the retarded.
Surprising Results with "Normal" Children
The results surprised her, for unlike her
retarded children who had to be prodded to use the materials,
these little ones were drawn to the work she introduced.
Children who had wandered aimlessly the week before began to
settle down to long periods of constructive activity. They were
fascinated with the puzzles and perceptual training devices.
But, to Montessori's amazement, children three and four
years-old took the greatest delight in learning practical
everyday living skills that reinforced their independence and
self-respect.
Children Transforming Themselves
Each day they begged her to show them more, even
applauding with delight when Montessori taught them the correct
use of a handkerchief. Soon the older children were taking care
of the school, assisting their teacher with the preparation and
serving of meals and the maintenance of a spotless environment.
Their behaviours as a group changed dramatically from street
urchins running wild to models of grace, and courtesy. It was
little wonder that the press found such a human interest story
appealing and promptly broadcast it to the world.
Follow the Child
Montessori education is sometimes criticized for
being too structured and academically demanding of young
children. Montessori would have laughed at this suggestion. She
often said, "I studied my children, and they taught me how to
teach them. "Montessori made a practice of paying close attention
to the their spontaneous behaviours, arguing that only in this way
could a teacher know how to teach. Traditionally schools pay
little attention to children as individuals, other than to
demand that they adapt to our standards. Montessori argued that
the educator's job is to serve the child; determining what each
one needs to make the greatest progress. To her, a child who
fails in school should not be blamed, any more than a doctor
should blame a patient who does not get well fast enough. After
all, it is the job of the physician to help us find the way to
cure ourselves, and the educator's job to facilitate the natural
process of learning.
Mathematics, Geometry and More
Montessori's children exploded into academics.
Too young to go to public school, they begged to be taught how
to read and write. They learned to do so quickly and
enthusiastically, using special manipulative materials that
Montessori designed for maximum appeal and effectiveness. The
children were fascinated by numbers; to meet this interest, the
mathematically inclined Montessori developed a series of
concrete Math learning materials that has never been surpassed.
Soon her four- and five-year-olds were performing four-digit
addition and subtraction operations, and in many cases pushing
on even farther. Their interests blossomed in other areas as
well, compelling a over-worked physician to spend night after
night designing new materials to keep pace with the children in
geometry, geography, history, and natural science.
Children Prefer Work Over Play
The final proof of the children's interest came
shortly after her first school became famous when a group of
well-intentioned women gave them a marvellous collection of
lovely and expensive toys. The new gifts held the children's
attention for a few days, but they soon returned to the more
interesting learning materials. To Montessori's surprise,
children who had experienced both preferred work over play most
of the time. If she were here today, Montessori would probably
add: 'Children read and do advanced Mathematics in Montessori
schools not because we push them, but because this is what they
do when given the correct setting and opportunity. To deny them
the right to learn because we, as adults, think that they
shouldn't is illogical and typical of the way schools have been
run before.'
A Method Continuously Refined
Montessori evolved her method through trial and
error, making educated guesses about the underlying meaning of
the children's actions. She was quick to pick up on their cues,
and constantly experimented with the class. For example,
Montessori tells of the morning when the teacher arrived late to
find that the children had crawled through a window and gone
right to work.
Children Can Select Their Own Work
At the beginning, the learning materials, having cost so much to
make, were locked away in a tall cabinet. Only the teacher had a
key and would open it and hand the materials to the children
upon request. In this instance the teacher had neglected to lock
the cabinet the night before. Finding it open, the children had
selected one material apiece and were working quietly. As
Montessori arrived the teacher was scolding the children for
taking them out without permission. She recognized that the
children's behaviours showed that they were capable of selecting
their own work, and removed the cabinet and replaced it with low
open shelves on which the activities were always available to
the children. Today this may sound like a minor change, but it
contradicted all educational practice and theory of that period.
Children Thrive On Concentration and Order
One discovery followed another, giving Montessori
an increasingly clear view of the inner mind of the child. She
found that little children were capable of long periods of quiet
concentration, even though they rarely show signs of it in
everyday settings. Although they are often careless and sloppy,
they respond positively to an atmosphere of calm and order.
Montessori noticed that the logical extension of the young
child's love for a consistent and often-repeated routine is an
environment in which everything has a place. Her children took
tremendous delight in carefully carrying their work to and from
the shelves, taking great pains not to bump into anything or
spill the smallest piece. They walked carefully through the
rooms, instead of running wildly as they did on the streets.
The Prepared Environment
Montessori discovered that the environment itself
was all important in obtaining the results that she had
observed. Not wanting to use school desks, she had carpenters
build child-sized tables and chairs. She was the first to do so,
recognizing the frustration that a little child experiences in
an adult sized world. Eventually she learned to design entire
schools around the size of the children. She had miniature
pitchers and bowls prepared, and found knives that fit a child's
tiny hand. The tables were light-weight, allowing two children
to move them alone. The children learned to control their
movements, disliking the way the calm was disturbed when they
knocked into things. Montessori studied the traffic pattern of
the rooms as well, arranging the furnishings and the activity
area to minimize congestion and tripping. The children loved to
sit on the floor, so she bought little rugs to define their work
areas and the children quickly learned to walk around them.
Discoveries Only Partially Implemented Through the
years, Montessori schools carried this environmental engineering
throughout the entire building and outside environment,
designing child-sized toilets and low sinks, windows low to the
ground, low shelves, and miniature hand and garden tools of all
sorts. Some of these ideas were eventually adapted by the larger
educational community, particularly at the nursery and
kindergarten levels. Many of the puzzles and educational devices
now in use at the preschool and elementary levels are direct
copies of Montessori's original ideas. However, there is far
more of her work that never entered the mainstream, and
educators who are searching for new, more effective answers are
finding the accumulated experience of the Montessori community
to be of great interest.
A Universal Solution
Maria Montessori's first "Children's House"
received overnight attention, and thousands of visitors came
away amazed and enthusiastic. World-wide interest surged as she
duplicated her first school in other settings with the same
results. Montessori captured the interest and imagination of
national leaders and scientists, mothers and teachers, labour
leaders and factory owners. As an internationally respected
scientist, Montessori had a rare credibility in a field where
many others had promoted opinions, philosophies, and models that
have not been readily duplicated. The Montessori method offered
a systematic approach that translates very well to new settings.
In the first thirty years of this century, the Montessori method
seemed to offer something for everyone. Conservatives
appreciated the calm, responsible behaviours of the little
children, along with their love for work. Liberals applauded the
freedom and spontaneity. Many political leaders saw it as a
practical way to reform the outmoded school systems of Europe
and North America, as well as an approach that they hoped would
lead to a more productive and law-abiding populace. Scientists
of all disciplines heralded its empirical foundation, along with
the accelerated achievement of the little children. Montessori
rode a wave of enthusiastic support that should have changed the
face of education far more dramatically than it has.
Dr. Montessori with her son, Mario Montessori Sr.
Development and Dissemination
Montessori's prime productive period lasted from
the opening of the first Children's House in 1907 until the
1930s. During this time, she continued her study of children,
and developed a vastly expanded curriculum and methodology for
the elementary level as well. Montessori schools were set up
throughout Europe and North America, and Dr. Montessori gave up
her medical practice to devote all of her energies to advocating
the rights and intellectual potential of all children.
Ideas Recognized But Not Integrated
During her lifetime, Dr. Montessori was
acknowledged as one of the world's leading educators. Education
moved beyond Maria Montessori, adapting only those elements of
her work that fit into existing theories and methods.
Ironically, the Montessori approach cannot be implemented as a
series of piecemeal reforms. It requires a complete
restructuring of the school and the teacher's role. Only
recently as our understanding of child development has grown
have we rediscovered how clear and sensible was her insight.
Today there is a growing consensus among psychologists and
developmental educators that many of her ideas were decades
ahead of their time.
As the movement gains support and begins to spread into the
American public school sector, one can readily say that
Montessori, begun ninety years ago, is a remarkably modern
approach.
A Montessori school somewhere in Africa circa
1920's.